Valentine’s Cookie Orders

Ms. Stugie’s Cookie Shoppe is ready to take your Valentine’s Day Orders. We will close the books when they fill up, or ‪on Monday, February 9, 2026 (whichever comes first). These orders will be pickup only.

Business Hours are Monday thru Friday 9:00am- 5:00pm and Saturday 10:00am- 1:00pm. Any requests received after the times listed will be returned the next business day.

Please note this is the only online store where Ms. Stugie's Cookie Shoppe cookies are sold. We do not sell on Etsy or any other setting.

gakentine galore -$14.99- $42.99

This set includes:
12- premium sugar cookies (3 shape)
3- bags of icing
3- bags of sprinkles
These cookies are ready to be decorated!
No prep work-just memories!
Note: Cookies will be bagged and heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

You are moovelous - $21.99

This set includes:

1 plaque, 1 heart shaped plaque, 1 $10 Chick-Fil-A Gift Card

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

I like your package - $38.99

This set includes:

1 plaque, 1 box shaped plaque, 1 $25 Gift Card

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

picture perfect -$17.99

This set includes:
1 Valentine’s Plaque and 3 Photo Plaques
*Send images to info@stugiescookies.com. List your order number in the Subject Line.
Note: Cookies will be bagged and heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

Kiss me - $11.99

This set includes:

1 Kiss Me plaque and 1 Lip plaque

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

Conversation Hearts - $15.99

This set includes:

4 Heart Shaped Plaques and 1 Edible Maker for writing

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

CLASSIC:DYO cookies -$19.99

This set includes:
4 Heart Photo Plaques
*Send images to info@stugiescookies.com. List your order number in the Subject Line.
Note: Cookies will be bagged and heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

Hearts by the dozen… - $24.99

This set includes:

1 plaque, 2 speech bubble plaques, 1 edible marker

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.

A piece of heart - $32.99

This set includes:

5- 5 packs of mini heart plaques.

Note: Cookies will not be heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.