Thanksgiving Cookie Orders

Ms. Stugie’s Cookie Shoppe is ready to take your Thanksgiving orders. We will close the books when they fill up, or ‪on Monday, November 19, 2018 (whichever comes first). These orders will be pickup only.

Business Hours are Monday thru Friday 9:00am- 4:00pm and Saturday 11:00am- 1:00pm. Any requests received after the times listed will be returned the next business day.

Please note this is the only online store where Ms. Stugie's Cookie Shoppe cookies are sold. We do not sell on Etsy or any other setting.

Decorate Your own (DYO) Cookie Box

1 Dozen premium sugar cookies (4 different shapes)
4 bags of icing
3 bags of sprinkles
Note: Cookies will be bagged and heat sealed. Cookies will not be placed on shredded paper. This display is for photo purposes only.🍪🍪


it’s a feat

Half dozen of double doozies.

elf on the shelf

Order your personalized Elf set today! This set is perfect for introducing your Elf or bringing your Elf back for another year. Your little one would love this!

The set consists of 1 Elf and 1 Note.


Gobble gobble

2 dozen (same flavor) of our Classic selection of cookies. Classic, Sugar Momma, Grammy Delight, or Pumpkin Spice and All Things Nice only.


Thanksgiving tic tac toe

A cookie Tic Tac Toe board with edible pieces.

sweet potato “pie” cookie

Show up to your Thanksgiving dinner with something different.

8 inch “pie”. 9 decorated cookies in a shape of a pie. 

Paint your own (pyo) cookie

Using the included brush and a tiny bit of water, your little one can wet the square cookie, turning them into watercolors! They can then paint their own cookie just like they would with a coloring page, creating their very own edible work of art!